received at different times and the "occasions" of revelations as narrated in the Muslim sources N?ldeke attempted to identify the dates of the Qur’ânic passages as well as of the sûrahs. In the process he discussed what he conceived to be the Judaeo-Christian origins of the Qur’ân, the nature of the Qur’ânic wahy, the nature and character of the Prophet and the literary merit of the Qur’ân, reflecting and reiterating more or less the same views as those of the other orientalists like George Sale, Aloys Sprenger and W. Muir. N?ldeke also dealt with the "collection" and publication of the entire Qur’ân during the times of ’Abû Bakr and ‘Uthmân.
In tracing the dates of the Qur’ânic passages (apart from the sûrahs) N?ldeke does not in most cases follow the "occasions" of revelations given in the Muslim sources but proceeds on two main assumptions, namely, (a) that many of the long sûrahs are the result of an amalgamation of various originally distinct revelations and, (b) the supposed differences in the literary style, "abrupt" changes in the subject matter and interruption in the connection of thought. On the basis of these two assumptions he severs out many pieces of long sûrahs as originally independent, assigning them supposed dates. His object in doing so is to show that the Qur’ân is, as he sees it, a patchwork of incoherent themes and episodes.
He follows more or less the same logic in tracing the chronological order of the sûrahs. Thus, he divides the sûrahs into four periods, the early Makkan, the mid-Makkan, the late Makkan and the Madinan, fixing the chronological order of each group according to the length, theme, literary style and what he conceived to be the "convulsive excitement" of the early group, the gradual diminishing of the glow and fervour of the middle and late Makkan groups and the "prosaic" tone of the Madinan group of sûrahs, using as far as it suits his purpose the known "occasions" of revelations. Needless to say that his chronological order of the sûrahs differs considerably from that given by the Muslim sources.
As regards the collection and publication of the Qur’ân under ’Abû Bakr and ‘Uthmân N?ldeke’s main assumptions are that Zayd ibn Thâbit collected the texts, "edited/redacted" them, combined the many originally independent passages into sûrahs and arranged them in the present order;